While many are familiar with the Amish’s traditional attire and values, their culinary heritage is often overlooked. This extensive list of 30 Amish recipes will transport you to a world where simplicity, community, and love for food come together in perfect harmony. The Amish’s roots stem from Europe, but it’s their unique blend of conservative values and emphasis on family that has shaped their approach to cooking over generations.
The Pennsylvania Dutch Community in Lancaster County is the oldest and largest Amish settlement in the United States, offering a glimpse into this tight-knit community. The Old Order Amish, in particular, are known for their rejection of modern technology, which has led to the preservation of traditional cooking methods and recipes.
Amish cuisine is characterized by hearty dishes, such as cabbage rolls and chicken casserole, alongside sweet treats like donuts and shoofly pie.
Their recipes often rely on simple, homemade ingredients and preparation methods that have been passed down through generations.
This collection of Amish food recipes showcases a range of meals, desserts, and snacks, including the famous Friendship Bread, Slow Cooker Amish Pot Roast, Amish Onion Patties, and tender Amish Apple Fritters. As you explore these recipes, you’ll discover that cooking from scratch can be a powerful way to appreciate the simple joys in life.
No Fail Amish White Bread
Beginning our culinary journey into the world of Amish cuisine, we’ll start with a classic staple: a delicious loaf of white bread, affectionately known as milk bread. This recipe offers more than just a tasty treat – it’s also an opportunity to learn valuable tips on yeast rising, troubleshooting common baking pitfalls, and exploring creative substitutions to enhance your baking experience.
Amish Sugar Cookies
When it comes to indulging in sweet treats, the Amish have mastered the art of simplicity and ease. One such delight is their scrumptious sugar cookies, which can be prepared without much fuss or fanfare. Unlike many other baked goods that require time-consuming tasks like rolling out, cutting, and icing, these cookies are a breeze to make. The best part? They’re perfectly enjoyable straight from the oven, with no need for elaborate toppings or decorations.
Amish Caramel Corn
While many classic recipes have been modernized over the years, there are some hidden gems in Amish cuisine that still retain their traditional charm. Case in point: caramel corn, a sweet and indulgent treat that’s perfect for snacking throughout the year.
Amish Cinnamon Muffins (Quick Amish Friendship Bread Muffins)
While some Amish recipes, such as the renowned Amish Friendship Bread, may require a significant investment of time, others offer a more expedient approach without compromising on flavor. A prime example is this recipe for scrumptious Amish cinnamon muffins, which delivers on its promise of a sweet treat in a relatively short amount of time.
Amish Country Casserole
This hearty Amish-style casserole is guaranteed to delight a diverse group of people. The combination of egg noodles, ground beef, savory sauce, aromatic seasonings, and melted cheese creates a truly mouthwatering experience.
Amish Glazed Donuts
Traditional Amish cooking is a testament to the power of preserving cultural heritage through culinary traditions. The recipes have been carefully passed down through generations, with each family adding their own unique touches and techniques. While the process may involve some nuances, such as the use of two ‘wet’ mixtures and varying rising times, the end result is well worth the effort.
In fact, having a friend or fellow cook to help with the process can make it an enjoyable and collaborative experience.
Amish Chicken And Noodles
There’s something undeniably comforting about a hearty serving of chicken and noodles, and this recipe from our curated collection of Amish dinner recipes embodies that warmth. While it may seem like a simple combination, the key to its wholesomeness lies in the perfectly cooked egg noodles, which add a satisfying depth to each bite.
Amish Baked Beans
Indulge in the rich flavors of Amish cuisine with these mouthwatering side dishes. One such standout recipe is for baked beans that strike the perfect balance between savory and sweet notes. This versatile dish can be paired with a variety of main courses, from classic burgers to sausage or even a veggie platter. The end result is well worth the four-hour cooking time – every minute spent waiting for these beans to finish is a testament to their undeniable deliciousness.
Slow Cooker Amish Pot Roast
Slow cooker Amish recipes have earned their reputation as culinary goldmines. The next recipe in line to impress is a mouthwatering pot roast dish that will exceed your expectations. One of the most intriguing aspects of this recipe is its unexpected use of coffee, which adds depth and richness to the overall flavor profile.
The combination of soy sauce, onion, and Worcestershire sauce further amplifies the bold flavors, making this roast a true showstopper.
After a leisurely nine hours on low in the slow cooker, the roast emerges tender and juicy, perfect for serving with your favorite sides.
Amish Broccoli Salad
Drawing inspiration from traditional Amish cuisine, we embarked on a culinary journey to uncover the authentic recipe for broccoli salad. This classic dish is a testament to the simplicity and flavor that can be achieved with just a few ingredients.
The Amish version we discovered features a harmonious blend of broccoli, mayonnaise, sour cream, salt, sugar, red onion, crispy bacon, and cheddar cheese – a straightforward yet satisfying combination that yields a dish that is both visually appealing and delectable.
Homemade Amish Lemon Bars
When browsing through the world of Amish desserts, it’s hard not to be drawn in by the allure of Amish lemon bars. The combination of a crumbly shortbread crust, a tangy and sweet lemon filling, and a generous sprinkle of powdered sugar on top is a match made in heaven. It’s no wonder these treats have earned their spot as a beloved classic, offering a simplicity and deliciousness that’s hard to resist.
Amish Pasta Salad
Pasta salad, an enduring classic, is a staple of traditional Amish cuisine. This beloved recipe is a masterclass in balance and variety, making it a crowd-pleaser at even the largest gatherings.
Amish Apple Fritters
While I use the term ‘Amish desserts’ liberally, some sweet treats from this tradition are versatile enough to fit seamlessly into various parts of the day. Take these crispy-on-the-outside, soft-on-the-inside apple fritters, for instance – they’re equally at home as a morning treat, an afternoon snack or a post-dinner dessert. The first time around, you might need a bit more guidance, but once you’ve got the process down, whipping up a batch will become second nature.
Amish Onion Patties
When it comes to Amish cooking, tradition is key, and that means relying on tried-and-true ingredients in innovative yet understated ways. A perfect example of this approach can be seen in the delightful onion patties that make a wonderful accompaniment to any meal. By combining these ingredients in a straightforward manner and then choosing between deep-frying or air-frying, you’ll be rewarded with crispy, flavorful morsels that are sure to please.
Amish Brown Butter Mashed Potatoes
When it comes to Amish cuisine, their culinary creations have a knack for stealing the spotlight at mealtime. And let me tell you, these mashed potatoes are no exception! The key to this delectable dish lies in its unexpected combination of ingredients, including cream cheese, garlic, milk, butter, and – the game-changer – browned butter. This unique blend of flavors will forever alter your perception of mashed potatoes, elevating them from a humble side dish to a truly show-stopping sensation.
Homemade Sloppy Joes
As we continue to delve into the world of Amish cuisine, Sloppy Joes take center stage. This hearty dish is a staple in many Amish households and for good reason – it’s incredibly easy to prepare and packed with flavor. To make this recipe, start by browning the hamburger and then add in some crispy bacon, sautéed onions, and all the other necessary ingredients. Let everything simmer together until the flavors have melded together perfectly.
The end result is a comforting meal that’s sure to hit the spot.
Amish Country Poor Man’s Hamburger Steaks
When exploring Amish dinner recipes, one can find creative ways to stretch their budget. One such example is the use of everyday ingredients like saltine cracker crumbs, which, when combined with milk and seasonings, can add texture and flavor to a dish. In this particular recipe, the addition of two cups of crushed crackers helps to thicken the mixture. Meanwhile, cream of mushroom soup serves as the base for the gravy, providing a rich and savory flavor profile.
This hearty dish is well-suited for serving alongside a side or a fresh green salad.
Amish Potato Rolls
As we explored the world of traditional bread, we’ve now turned our attention to a classic recipe from the Amish community – potato rolls. The promise of easy, fluffy, and flavorful ingredients is what makes this recipe truly special. When it comes to holiday gatherings, these tender rolls are sure to be the star of the show.
Classic Amish Oatmeal Pie
For those who adore pecan pie, prepare for a delightful surprise. The Amish oatmeal pie, born from traditional recipes, is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. This delectable dessert has its roots in post-war era, when pecans were scarce and the Amish community cleverly substituted oatmeal as a substitute. What’s remarkable about this treat is not only its simplicity but also the depth of flavors it presents. And the best part? It’s perfect for enjoying with a scoop of creamy ice cream on top.
Amish Pumpkin Cinnamon Rolls With Caramel Icing
Indulge in the quintessential flavors of autumn with pumpkin cinnamon rolls smothered in rich caramel icing. This recipe, inspired by traditional Amish cooking methods, is a surefire way to kick off the cozy season. What’s more, you can prep these treats partially ahead of time, freeing up your schedule for other fall festivities.
Amish Chicken And Waffles
While Amish dinner recipes may come in various forms, this particular variation draws inspiration from the traditional Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine, where waffles served as a substitute for dumplings or potatoes.
Amish One-Pan Ground Beef And Cabbage Skillet
When it comes to Amish-inspired cooking, simplicity and affordability are key characteristics. Take this one-pan beef and cabbage recipe as an example – not only is it budget-friendly, but its versatility also shines through in the numerous variations that can be made using ingredients on hand or in season. The beauty of this recipe lies in its ability to bring together flavors and textures, culminating in a satisfying and filling entree that’s perfect for any occasion.
Amish Friendship Carrot Cake
The versatility of using a sourdough starter is showcased in the creation of numerous Amish desserts. One such example is the moist and flavorful carrot cake, rich in the warm spices of cinnamon, the sweetness of coconut, and the natural goodness of carrots. The crowning glory of this dessert is the indulgent cream cheese frosting, providing a delightful contrast to the wholesome ingredients.
Homemade Amish Pretzels
It’s fascinating how, for many cooks, one particular recipe stands out as a go-to favorite – often referred to as the penultimate choice. In the realm of traditional Amish cuisine, these beloved recipes consistently rise to the top. And when it comes to baked pretzels, this compilation is truly in a league of its own. With its tried-and-true techniques and mouthwatering results, everyone will be eager to get involved in creating their very own scrumptious homemade pretzel.
Amish Roast Turkey (Or Chicken) And Dressing Casserole
The world of Amish cuisine is renowned for its hearty and comforting dishes. One classic recipe that exemplifies this is a delectable casserole dish featuring chicken or turkey as the main protein. The recipe typically includes a combination of chunky bread, sautéed vegetables, an egg-based mixture, broth, and finally, a baking process that brings all the flavors together in perfect harmony.
The end result is a culinary masterpiece that would be just as satisfying on any given day, but especially after a big feast like Thanksgiving.
Amish Sausage Stuffed Green Peppers
When it comes to exploring the world of Amish cuisine, one dish that stands out is a simple yet flavorful combination of Italian sausage, green peppers, and tomato soup. The savory filling, infused with the richness of the sausage and the tanginess of the soup, is both satisfying and aromatic. Paired with fresh, crunchy green peppers baked to perfection, this hearty entree is sure to impress.
Amish Apple Bread
While traditional baking methods often require patience and time for yeast to rise, this apple bread recipe offers a quicker alternative. The result is a sweet and tender loaf that’s reminiscent of cake, boasting an extra layer of sweetness. Adding an element of surprise, the brown sugar caramel sauce provides a delightful contrast in flavors.
The Easiest Amish Egg Noodles
When it comes to traditional Amish cuisine, egg noodles are a staple that frequently appears in old recipes. Rather than simply acknowledging their presence, let’s dive into the world of preparing and incorporating these versatile noodles into your cooking repertoire. Whether you choose to serve them as a standalone side dish or incorporate them into a hearty casserole, the possibilities are endless.
Just be prepared for a rich and savory experience, as egg noodles often require a generous amount of butter and broth to bring out their full flavor.
5-Minute Amish Peanut Butter Spread
While some traditional Amish recipes have undergone modern adaptations to accommodate personal preferences and lifestyle changes, this classic recipe has been reimagined with a twist. The result is a peanut butter spread that replaces refined sugars with the natural sweetness of maple syrup. This sweet and creamy concoction can be enjoyed as a delicious topping for breads or as a dip for an assortment of fresh fruits.
Seasoned Snack Crackers (Amish Recipe)
Why not give homemade crackers a try? The simplicity of this recipe makes it an ideal DIY project. Inspired by traditional Amish recipes, we’ll show you how to elevate plain saltines with a flavorful combination of cream, onion powder, and cheddar cheese powder – available for online ordering if needed. With just a few ingredients, you can create crunchy, delicious crackers that are perfect for snacking or serving alongside your favorite dips.
The bottom line
Indulging in the joy of cooking often begins with taking a moment to slow down, allowing the opportunity to thoughtfully plan and prepare a delectable homemade meal. It’s a rare pleasure that many of us savor.
