When it comes to indulging in the ultimate breakfast or snack, few can deny the allure of a perfectly toasted bagel. The perfect union of crispy crust and soft interior, paired with an array of mouthwatering toppings, makes for a culinary experience that’s hard to beat. Whether you’re in need of a quick energy boost or simply craving something satisfying, bagels are the ultimate comfort food.
And while classic cream cheese or plain combinations are always a safe bet, there’s also something to be said for venturing beyond the ordinary and exploring the world of creative bagel toppings. From light and refreshing options to hearty and filling indulgences, there’s a whole realm of flavor possibilities waiting to be discovered.
Bagel topping ideas
The versatility of bagels lies in the countless combinations of toppings one can create, making every bite a delightful experience. From classic pairings to innovative fusions, each topping brings its own distinct charm and flavor profile. Among my top picks are…
Nutella and strawberries
Indulge in the rich flavors of chocolate and hazelnut by spreading a generous amount of Nutella on top of freshly toasted bagels. The velvety smoothness of this decadent spread is the perfect canvas for a stunning combination: halved strawberries add natural sweetness, while sprinkled chopped hazelnuts provide a satisfying crunch and nutty depth.
Garden fresh with cream cheese
Elevate your bagel game with this unique cream cheese topping combination. By blending ΒΌ cup of fresh dill with 1 cup of softened cream cheese, you’ll create a spread that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds. Allow the mixture to chill for approximately 2 hours before spreading it over your bagels and finishing them off with a crunchy medley of shredded zucchini and carrots. This refreshing twist on traditional toppings will leave you craving more.
Another cream cheese!
To take your cream cheese game to the next level, try combining one and three-quarters cup of zesty key lime juice with a single cup of softened cream cheese. Allow this mixture to chill in the refrigerator for approximately two hours before spreading it generously over your bagels. For added texture and flavor, sprinkle the cream cheese with toasted macadamia nuts, shredded coconut, and a pinch of grated key lime peel.
Avocados
Give your avocado toast a creative spin by adding this tasty bagel topping! While avocados already pair beautifully with bagels due to their rich, creamy texture and adaptability, you can take it to the next level by incorporating a poached egg. The silky yolk and firm white provide a delightful contrast to the chunky avocado, making for an indulgent breakfast or snack.
PB&J
The quintessential comfort food combination is one that never goes out of style: the harmonious union of creamy peanut butter and sweet red apple jelly on top of freshly baked bagels. This timeless topping is the ultimate pick-me-up, evoking feelings of warmth and coziness with every bite.
Pizza, pizza, pizza!
Transform your average bagel into a savory masterpiece by experimenting with creative topping combinations. For a pizza-inspired twist, start by spreading spicy marinara sauce onto your fresh bagel, followed by a layer of melted mozzarella cheese and crispy pepperoni slices. To take it to the next level, simply microwave the bagel for 1-2 minutes to achieve that perfectly gooey cheese experience.
Ham and cheddar
When it comes to bagel toppings, simplicity can often be the best option. For many people, there’s no beating the classic combination of ham and cheese. It’s a match made in heaven that’s easy to prepare and always hits the spot. Simply place some sliced ham and melted cheese between two toasted bagels, and you’re rewarded with a satisfying snack or light meal.
Chicken parmesan
Transform your leftover breaded chicken parmesan into an unexpected yet mouthwatering combination by placing it atop a toasted bagel. Elevate the dish further by drizzling rich marinara sauce and sprinkling melted mozzarella cheese for a harmonious blend of flavors and textures. The resulting union of crispy, savory chicken, tangy marinara, and crunchy bagel creates a truly enchanting culinary experience.
The Caprese style
Elevate your bagel game by experimenting with the Caprese style – a harmonious blend of pesto sauce, mozzarella, and fresh tomatoes. This delectable combination is sure to delight even the most discerning palates. For an added layer of indulgence, consider topping it off with creamy burrata cheese, which will transport your taste buds to new heights.
How to serve bagels
When it comes to serving bagels, you have the flexibility to keep things simple with a classic cream cheese topping or get creative with various toppings. Another option is to use your favorite fillings as sandwich ingredients, placing them neatly between two bagels. For instance, you can assemble a satisfying BLT or a breakfast-inspired combination featuring crispy bacon, scrambled eggs, and melted cheese.
Tips and tricks
When it comes to bagel toppings, there are a few key tips to keep in mind. One important consideration is the temperature of your bagel. If you’re planning to spread soft cream cheese on a hot bagel, be aware that it will melt and potentially drip everywhere. To avoid this mess, I recommend letting the bagel cool slightly before applying the cream cheese. This way, you can still enjoy the benefits of creamy toppings without the hassle of cleanup.
Another clever trick is to use cream cheese as a ‘glue’ to keep other ingredients in place. Simply spread a thin layer on your bagel and then add your chosen toppings – such as diced green onions or capers – which will stick nicely to the cheese. Finally, when it comes time to cut your bagel, don’t forget to use a serrated knife to get clean cuts. To do this, place the bagel flat on the counter and cut it horizontally in half, then stand it upright and finish cutting.
This technique ensures that you end up with two evenly cut halves, perfect for topping and serving.
The bottom line
Next time you’re stuck in a breakfast rut, trading in your plain-cream-cheese-only bagel for something more exciting. I’ve uncovered nine game-changing toppings that will revolutionize your morning routine and leave you wondering how you ever settled for anything less. And don’t worry, I won’t stop there – I’ll also provide some inspiration on how to serve these tasty combinations.
Try them as a standalone snack or get creative with bagel sandwiches by layering the toppings between two crispy bagels. From classic PB&J to creamy avocado spreads, this list has something for everyone. So go ahead, take your morning routine to the next level and indulge in the ultimate bagel topping experience!
