15 Best Copycat Crumbl Cookies Recipes

Crumbl cookies have taken the world by storm with their vast array of over 200 unique cookie offerings, each one a masterclass in flavor and visual appeal. The brand’s menu is a veritable treasure trove of sweet treats, featuring an impressive range of cookie varieties that draw inspiration from various desserts.

One of the most intriguing aspects of Crumbl’s menu is its rotating selection of four to five different cookie flavors and variants each week, ensuring that fans are always in for a surprise. However, this also means that many beloved cookies may only be available for a limited time, leaving enthusiasts eager to recreate their favorite treats at home.

As such, the world of copycat Crumbl cookies has emerged as a way for fans to get creative and re-create some of these beloved sweet treats.

Whether you’re looking to whip up party snacks or desserts for loved ones, or even start your own cookie business with a unique twist on the originals, copycat recipes offer an exciting opportunity to get in on the action.

From colorful treats like Confetti Cake and Funfetti Cookies to decadent chocolatey delights like Copycat Oreo Crumbl Cookies, there’s something for everyone in this world of creative cookie-making.

If you’re eager to dive into the world of copycat Crumbl cookies, look no further! Below, we’ve rounded up 15 mouthwatering copycat recipes that re-create some of the most beloved sweet treats on the Crumbl menu.

Buttermilk Pancake Crumbl Cookie

Buttermilk Pancake Crumbl Cookie

At first blush, the Copycat Buttermilk Pancake Crumbl may appear to be a run-of-the-mill butter cookie adorned with a dollop of frosting. But upon closer inspection, it reveals itself to be a masterfully crafted treat comprising three distinct components: the soft and chewy cookie base, the rich buttermilk glaze, and the creamy frosting crowning the top.

The harmonious union of these elements elevates this cookie from mere mortal status to a truly tantalizing treat that will leave you wanting more.

Carrot Cake Crumbl Cookie

Carrot cakes may seem like an unusual combination, but once you take a bite, the magic unfolds. This unique cookie recipe takes a different approach by incorporating shredded carrots into the dough, giving each morsel a distinct appearance.

To add another layer of complexity, a sweet and tangy cream cheese spread is paired with crunchy pecan nuts on top, mimicking the flavors found in the popular Crumbl delicacy. It’s an unexpected twist that will leave you wanting more.

Cinnamon Swirl Crumbl Cookie

Cinnamon Swirl Crumbl Cookie

Get ready for a flavor adventure with our copycat Cinnamon Swirl Crumbl snacks! The secret to their irresistible taste lies in the harmonious blend of butter, vanilla, sugar, and cinnamon, which creates a delightful balance of spicy-sweet notes that will tantalize your taste buds. To take this cookie recipe to the next level, we add a trio of cream cheese, butter, and cinnamon as swirled frostings beneath a rich, brown sweet cinnamon topping that will leave you wanting more.

Churro Crumbl Cookie

Churros are beloved finger foods that boast a simple yet indulgent combination of fried dough coated in a sweet and spicy sugar-cinnamon mixture. While traditional churros are indeed delightful, they can also be reimagined as a cookie for a unique twist. Taking the essence of churros and translating it into a cookie format allows for an equally satisfying treat.

To elevate this cookie to new heights, consider topping it with a generous swirl of cinnamon buttercream frosting, adding an extra layer of warmth and depth to this sweet indulgence.

Confetti Cake Crumbl Cookie

Confetti Cake Crumbl Cookie

Imagine a party in every bite with confetti cakes, also affectionately known as rainbow cakes. This beloved treat is a favorite among both kids and adults alike. But here’s the exciting part – you can easily recreate these vibrant pastries as copycat Crumbl cookies! To achieve this, simply add colorful pastel quins to your cookie dough and cream cheese frosting.

As you bite into the buttery cookie base, the added quins will burst forth with even more color, taking the treat to a whole new level of fun. And don’t forget, you can customize the look further by choosing your preferred colored frosting – let your imagination run wild!

Cornbread Crumbl Cookie

Cornbread Crumbl Cookie

A traditional Native American pastry, cornbread has a rich history that dates back to ancient times. Typically made from cornmeal or powdered dried corn, it’s no surprise that this beloved treat has evolved into a versatile cookie dough. This copycat Crumbl cookie recipe takes inspiration from the classic cornbread ingredients, cleverly reimagining them as a sweet and indulgent afternoon snack.

By incorporating honey buttercream frosting and a drizzle of pure honey, you’ll be treated to a delightful combination that’s sure to please even the most discerning palates.

Dulce De Leche Crumbl Cookie

Dulce De Leche Crumbl Cookie

Dulce de leche, a beloved confection from Latin America and beyond, is essentially caramelized milk. While its rich brown hue and thick consistency may not be immediately apparent, the process of making dulce de leche typically involves stirring milk and sugar together for an extended period. This sweet treat is often incorporated into a diverse range of baked goods, including breads, pastries, and confections.

And, as luck would have it, you can even indulge in its sweet delight within your own homemade Crumbl cookie copycat recipe. The alternating cream cheese and caramel swirls already make these cookies visually appealing, but the variety of flavors they bring to each bite is what truly sets them apart.

Funfetti Crumbl Cookie

Indulge in the whimsical world of colorful cookie snacks! The Funfetti Crumbl, reminiscent of the iconic Confetti Cake Crumbl, takes the cue from its predecessor by incorporating an array of vibrant hues, courtesy of a generous sprinkling of candy bits evenly distributed throughout the dough. The result is a visually striking treat that’s sure to delight both young and old alike.

Feeling extra festive?

Simply add as many sprinkles as your heart desires to create a party snack that’s equal parts tantalizing and Instagram-worthy. And who can blame you? This copycat Funfetti Crumbl is destined to become a crowd-pleaser, satisfying the cravings of both kids and adults alike with its sweet, buttery goodness.

New York Cheesecake Crumbl Cookie

When venturing to New York, it’s easy to get caught up in the iconic landmarks and attractions. However, the Empire State is also renowned for its delectable cuisine and regional specialties. Take, for instance, the numerous pizzerias serving up classic New York-style pizzas or the various food stalls offering a diverse array of dishes. But did you know that cheesecakes are another beloved staple in this state?

Yes, New York has its own unique brand of creamy cheesecake with a delicate cake texture and a chewy butter graham crust. While indulging in a slice of authentic NYC Cheesecake is certainly an experience, there’s no need to travel all the way to New York City to satisfy your cravings. Instead, try this copycat Crumbl cookie recipe inspired by the classic cheesecake.

Although not as soft and airy as the original, these cookies retain much of the signature flavors, including the graham cracker dough and the cream cheese and vanilla frosting, making them a delightful treat that can be enjoyed anywhere.

Oatmeal Crumbl Cookie

Oatmeal Crumbl Cookie

While oatmeal cookies are already a staple snack, you can elevate the classic recipe by drawing inspiration from the popular Crumbl cookie. To create an authentic Oatmeal Crumbl treat at home, start by preparing a rich glaze consisting of milk, sugar, and vanilla extract. This sweet and creamy topping perfectly complements the nutty flavor of the oatmeal, resulting in a snack that’s both familiar and indulgent.

Oreo Crumbl Cookie

Oreo Crumbl Cookie

Oreos are a beloved treat thanks to their decadent chocolate wafers and velvety vanilla filling. But what if you want to take your Oreo love to the next level? One way to do so is by attempting this copycat Crumbl cookie recipe, which leverages the classic cookie’s rich flavors. The best part? You can also use crushed Oreos to construct towering layers of frosted goodness, incorporating cream cheese for an added depth of sweetness that’s sure to satisfy your cravings.

Peppermint Bark Crumbl Cookie

Peppermint Bark Crumbl Cookie

This copycat Peppermint Bark Crumbl Cookie is a delightful treat that embodies the perfect balance of sweet and refreshing. The star of the show is undoubtedly the peppermint canes, a beloved mint candy among children. What sets this cookie apart is its crumbly chocolate base topped with cream cheese frosting and crushed peppermint cane, adding a satisfying crunch to each bite. The combination of textures and flavors makes for a truly irresistible snack.

Raspberry Cheesecake Crumbl Cookie

Raspberry Cheesecake Crumbl Cookie

Elevate your sweet cheesecake cookie snack to new heights by incorporating tart raspberry flavor into this scrumptious copycat Raspberry Cheesecake Crumbl. This delightful treat features a buttery graham cookie base topped with a rich cream cheese frosting and finished with a drizzle of sweet and tangy raspberry jam, reminiscent of the classic Raspberry Cheesecake. With its perfect balance of flavors and textures, these irresistible cookie treats are sure to bring joy to everyone who indulges.

S’mores Crumbl Cookie

S’mores Crumbl Cookie

While belting out the iconic C-A-M-P-F-I-R-E-S-O-N-G song with our friends from Bikini Bottom, why not indulge in some delicious S’mores? These sweet treats are a staple at many camping trips, particularly around campfires. Typically, they consist of toasted marshmallows sandwiched between two graham biscuits and a layer of chocolate. However, you can also create your own S’mores-inspired Crumbl by incorporating small marshmallows into the dough.

To take it to the next level, try adding a marshmallow on top before baking for a soft, chewy texture reminiscent of traditional campfire treats.

Chocolate Turtle Crumbl Cookie

Chocolate Turtle Crumbl Cookie

In a delightful twist, the Chocolate Turtle Crumbl takes the concept of ‘crumble’ quite literally. The cookies have an uncanny resemblance to turtle shells, boasting a fragile appearance that’s both intriguing and inviting.

The real magic happens when you take a bite – these chewy treats are surprisingly satisfying. The addition of crunchy pecan nuts adds a delightful textural contrast that elevates the experience.

To elevate this cookie to new heights, consider drizzling it with a rich chocolate and caramel. This sweet and indulgent touch is sure to make your taste buds do the happy dance.

The bottom line

Crumbl’s meteoric rise to fame can be attributed to several factors, which have collectively contributed to its widespread appeal and cult-like following. The company’s commitment to using only the finest ingredients, combined with its innovative approach to cookie design, has resonated deeply with customers seeking a sweet treat that’s both indulgent and Instagram-worthy.

Leave a Comment