Are you eager to get creative with eggnog in your recipes? We’ve got just the thing – 30 easy-to-make Eggnog Cocktails that will make your holiday celebrations even more festive! But before we dive into the recipes, let’s take a quick journey through time. Eggnog, or as it was once known, milk punch or egg-milk punch, has been around for centuries.
Its origins are shrouded in mystery, with some claiming it comes from Old English terms for ‘strong beer’ or ‘small cup’, while others believe it’s tied to the word ‘grogs’, which referred to strong beverages. Whatever its true origin, eggnog is a culinary descendant of posset, a warm ale punch with eggs that European monks enjoyed as early as the 13th century.
And let’s be real – eggnog can definitely pack a punch, adding festive cheer and maybe even a little too much holiday cheer to your gatherings! But don’t worry, we’ve got recipes for all levels of drinkers, from those who like their eggnog straight up to those who prefer it mixed with other ingredients. From Ube Eggnog Spiked Cocktail to Eggnog Mexican Hot Chocolate, and George Washington’s own Eggnog recipe, there’s something for everyone.
So grab your favorite mug and get ready to shake (or stir) things up with our 30 fantastic eggnog cocktails!
Holiday Spiked Eggnog
The essence of the festive season can be distilled into one perfectly crafted cocktail. The harmonious blend of amaretto and white rum creates a rich, velvety concoction that’s sure to impress. To take it to the next level, simply add a sprig of warm cinnamon, allowing its aromatic properties to mingle with the liquor. This seasonal sipper is the epitome of holiday cheer.
Traditional Rum Eggnog
When combining rum and eggnog, the former’s inherent sweetness effectively counterbalances the rich, eggy flavor of the latter. This harmonious balance is a significant advantage when considering mixer options for this holiday classic.
In lieu of almond extract, amaretto can be utilized as a substitute, although it will imbue the drink with a slightly stronger character.
Chocolate Eggnog Martini
While the original recipe employs Kahlúa, which boasts a flavor profile closer to coffee than chocolate, you’re free to substitute it with a rich and decadent chocolate liqueur from brands like Godiva. As for the finishing touches, be sure to top off your drink with a thoughtful garnish that adds an extra layer of visual appeal and aromatics.
Ube Eggnog Spiked Cocktail
In just three ingredients, you’re all set to create a fantastic drink! The real showstopper, however, is the crushed ube polvoron that rims the glass. For those who may not be familiar with this delightful ingredient, ube refers to the purple yam, a staple in Filipino cuisine. To make this recipe kid-friendly, simply omit the rum and you’re good to go!
Mrs. Claus Cocktail
Imagine sipping on a drink that embodies the essence of the holiday season: smooth, velvety, and sweet. This indulgent concoction is sure to evoke feelings of warmth and cheer. To take your festive experience to the next level, consider adding a touch of whimsy with crushed candy as a garnish or rimming the glass with its colorful sweetness.
Eggnog White Russian
Elevate your holiday gathering with a creative twist on traditional cocktails. This unique blend combines the warmth of vodka and Kahlúa for a festive treat. For an added layer of flavor, simply adjust the ratio of spirits to eggnog, allowing you to customize the drink’s potency to suit your taste preferences. Whether you prefer a stronger or more mellow beverage, this versatile recipe offers endless possibilities.
Iced Eggnog Latte
Whether you’re looking to kick-start your morning or unwind after a long day, coffee is often the perfect companion. When paired with the rich flavors of eggnog, the cooling touch of ice, and a sprinkle of nutmeg, it’s easy to see why this unique blend has become a holiday favorite for many.
White Chocolate Mint Eggnog
Indulge in the sweet surprise of a boozy dessert that’s meant to be sipped, not savored. Elevate its flavor profile with a flourish of sugared cranberries and a sprig of fresh mint for a pop of color and fragrance.
Hazelnut Eggnog With Bourbon & Cloves
Whether you prefer your beverage served ice-cold or at a cozy temperature, it pairs exquisitely well with a variety of sweet treats and morning meals alike.
Spiced Coconut Eggnog
While traditional eggnog recipes may not immediately spring to mind when thinking of coconut oil, the creamy liquid can actually be used to create a distinctively flavored drink. This unique taste profile can be further enhanced by adding optional liquors like rum and brandy, which will undoubtedly give your eggnog mix an added kick.
Eggnog Milkshake
Sipping on a cold milkshake is a quintessential summer delight. But, what happens when you combine it with the rich flavors of eggnog? The result is a surprisingly sweet and velvety drink that’s perfect for hot summer days and lazy afternoons. And, if you’re feeling extra indulgent, why not top it off with some creamy ice cream to take it to the next level?
Eggnog Espresso Martini With Rum
When it comes to coffee, people often have strong preferences when it comes to their ideal cup. Some like theirs extra sweet, while others prefer a rich and creamy texture. But what if you could combine the bold flavors of martini and rum with the warm, comforting taste of eggnog? This unique espresso mix offers just that – a delightful blend of robust and sweet notes that’s perfect for sipping on special occasions or cozying up at home during the holiday season.
Spiked Eggnog Italian Soda
Italian soda’s vibrant appeal stems from its harmonious blend of soda water and flavorful syrups. The addition of ice and whipped cream adds a delightful textural element to this refreshing beverage. One popular variation is the use of eggnog, which lends a light yellow hue and creamy consistency. For those looking to elevate their drink game, a splash of rum can introduce a unique flavor dimension, catering to individual tastes.
Eggnog Mexican Hot Chocolate
Indulge in the delightful union of chocolate and eggnog, as demonstrated by this indulgent Eggnog Mexican Hot Chocolate recipe. The perfect blend for a sweet treat that can be enjoyed hot or chilled to perfection. To take it to the next level, consider topping it with soft marshmallows and fluffy whipped cream for an added layer of decadence.
Eggnog Orange Julius
Although Orange Julius has discontinued many of its signature drinks in recent years, the brand’s most iconic beverage – iced orange juice blended with vanilla and milk – remains a beloved favorite among fans. Despite the decline in availability, some stores have continued to serve this classic drink, sparking a wave of creative copycat recipes that cater to the nostalgia and cravings of Orange Julius enthusiasts.
One such recipe is Eggnog Orange Julius, which masterfully combines rich creaminess with tangy sweetness, appealing to both those who grew up with Orange Julius and newcomers alike.
Eggnog Pudding Shots
While eggnog is commonly enjoyed as a beverage, few people realize the delightful alternative: a rich and creamy spoonful of eggnog pudding. These bite-sized treats offer a unique and enjoyable experience for both kids and adults, making them an excellent addition to any social gathering or celebration.
Bourbon Eggnog
While it may seem counterintuitive at first, pairing eggnog with bourbon reveals a harmonious union. Our previous recipes have already demonstrated that combining eggnog with various ingredients is not only possible but also yields exciting results. In this particular instance, incorporating eggnog into the bourbon has an intriguing effect: it tempers the boldness of the liquor and infuses the drink with the richness of dairy, creating a unique and enjoyable taste experience.
Rumchata Eggnog
While Eggnog and Rumchata may seem like vastly distinct holiday drinks, they can actually complement each other quite well. Rumchata, a sweet vanilla and cinnamon Caribbean rum, boasts a unique flavor profile that pairs surprisingly well with eggnog’s creamy texture and subtle sweetness. Furthermore, both beverages share a striking visual similarity, transitioning from white to yellow hues – making them a harmonious combination.
Cinnamon Gingerbread Eggnog
Another festive recipe that’s perfect for holiday gatherings is the Cinnamon Gingerbread Eggnog. What sets this eggnog apart from others is its unique blend of warm spices, including cinnamon and the unmistakable flavor of gingerbread, which gives it a delightful twist.
Pumpkin Eggnog With Bourbon
Imagine the rich aroma of pumpkin puree blending harmoniously with the creamy smoothness of eggnog. The unconventional fusion is already intriguing. Then, introduce the bold and complex notes of bourbon to create a truly unique concoction that will tantalize the taste buds of those who appreciate the art of combining spirits with indulgent treats.
Boozy Pumpkin Pie Shooters
Imagine turning your beloved pumpkin pie into a refreshing beverage. The Pumpkin Pie Shooters recipe achieves just that by combining eggnog and pumpkin puree with vodka for an added depth of flavor. While these shooters are perfect for adult gatherings and parties, they may not be suitable for children due to the inclusion of alcohol. However, it’s also possible to create a kid-friendly version sans booze, making them a delightful option for adults and kids alike.
Santa’s Magic Potion
Santa’s magic potion is often shrouded in mystery, but the truth behind its concoction is quite straightforward. This enchanted elixir is none other than Baileys Irish Cream, a unique blend of chocolate and cream whiskey that adds a rich velvety texture to any drink. When combined with the classic wintery flavors of eggnog, this potion creates a chilled and creamy beverage that’s perfect for sipping on Christmas mornings or as an everyday indulgence.
Eggnog Brandy Alexander
The Brandy Alexander is a classic cocktail recipe that combines the richness of brandy with the indulgence of chocolate. For those looking to give this drink a seasonal twist, substituting the traditional chocolate and cream components with eggnog creates a deliciously creamy and velvety concoction when mixed with brandy. This unique variation makes for an excellent party cocktail, perfect for impressing your guests at your next gathering.
Eggnog Vodka Cocktail
When you combine the bold flavors of vodka with the rich, creamy texture of eggnog, something truly unique and delicious is born – the Eggnog Vodka Cocktail. This festive drink requires a precise balance of its two main ingredients to achieve a harmonious blend of sweet and savory notes that’s perfect for cozying up on a chilly night.
Chai Eggnog
Masala Chai, or simply Chai, is a rich and complex beverage originating from India. This black tea-based drink is often misunderstood as having a straightforward earthy taste. On the contrary, it’s a harmonious blend of creamy, sweet, and spicy notes that make it a perfect pairing for other festive drinks like eggnog.
The unique combination of ingredients in Chai Eggnog creates an equally balanced flavor profile, with thick, creamy, and sweet elements working together to create a delightful experience.
Puerto Rican Rum Eggnog
In a twist on traditional eggnog recipes, this Puerto Rican-inspired drink is affectionately known as ‘Coquito.’ Unlike other versions, it eschews eggs altogether, earning it the moniker ‘eggless eggnog.’ Instead, it relies on a trio of rich and creamy ingredients: coconut milk, evaporated milk, and condensed milk. To add depth and warmth, vanilla extract provides a subtle yet inviting flavor profile.
The drink’s tropical essence is further enhanced by the addition of rum, lending a bold and adventurous spirit to this unique beverage.
The Yule Log Cocktail
In the world of festive cocktails, few drinks evoke the magic of Christmas quite like the Yule Log. This beloved beverage’s simplicity is part of its charm, relying solely on the harmonious union of sweet fireball whiskey and eggnog to create a taste experience that’s equal parts warm and inviting. It’s a far cry from the rich, chocolatey delights often associated with the actual Yule Log – a decadent Christmas cake that’s just as indulgent as it is delicious.
Orange Spiced Eggnog
Blending the sweetness of oranges with the richness of eggnog creates a unique flavor profile in this spiced beverage. The addition of Cointreau, an orange liqueur, adds a candy-like taste that complements the creamy texture of traditional eggnog. For those seeking an extra boost, rum can be added to give the drink a much-needed kick.
George Washington’s Eggnog
While it’s unlikely that George Washington himself crafted this eggnog recipe, its intriguing ingredients have sparked curiosity. The presence of whiskey, brandy, and Jamaican rum lends a robust character to the drink, making it more suitable for adults than young ones or those unfamiliar with strong spirits. Despite the disputed origins, this eggnog’s potent combination of liquors remains an interesting historical footnote.
Peppermint Eggnog White Hot Chocolate
Indulge in the ultimate cozy moment by crafting a scrumptious treat that will leave you feeling warm and fuzzy inside. The combination of velvety goodness and crunchy textures is a match made in heaven. Imagine sinking your teeth into a marshmallow-topped delight, sprinkled with crushed peppermints for an added burst of flavor. It’s the perfect recipe for a night by the fireplace, where the only thing that’ll melt is the chocolate – not your heart.
The bottom line
Eggnog, like pumpkin spice, is a seasonal ingredient that can be enjoyed year-round. However, its versatility makes it an excellent addition to various dishes and drinks. With over 30 eggnog recipes to explore, we’re excited to share some creative twists on this classic treat. For those who crave something new, our list of eggnog treats offers a world of possibilities.
If you’re an eggnog enthusiast looking to venture beyond the traditional recipe, we invite you to try these rich and delicious concoctions. For added inspiration, check out our original Overnight Homemade Eggnog recipe. And for a festive touch, indulge in one of our 30 easy eggnog cocktails, perfect for parties and gatherings.
